On Structural Autonomy of Scientific Theories and Value Systems. A Polemic with Professor Anna Jedynak

Abstract

The paper is a critique of Professor Anna Jedynak's claim, propounded in her article "The structure of scientific theories and value systems" (Filozofia Nauki, no. 31-32/2000, pp. 31-44), that there exist some significant analogies between scientific theories perceived from the viewpoint of various scientific methodologies and systems of normative ethics considered from the perspectives of various metaethical theories. The authors attempt to justify the thesis that principal structural similarities postulated by Professor Jedynak are questionable, thus challenging her proposition that metaethics can incorporate into its domain a number of problems which were hitherto seen as specific to the philosophy of science.