The Ineffable Case of Expressives



Słowa kluczowe:

expressives, descriptives, descriptive ineffability


Expressive terms (damn, fuck, bastard) are said to convey speakers’ attitudes and feelings. These can be positive or negative, depending on the context. In this paper, I focus on the property of expressives that I take to be of the most importance: descriptive ineffability. Descriptive ineffability is a property of expressive terms for which no suitable descriptive paraphrase can be found that
captures the full meaning of the expressive. In the face of arguments that attempt to show either that descriptive terms also carry this feature or that expressives (at least in some instances) can be effable, I defend the idea that descriptive ineffability is unique to expressives. I end the paper by considering what descriptive ineffability can teach us about expressive terms.


Belleri D. (2014a), Semantic Under-Determinacy and Communication, London: Palgrave Macmillan.

Belleri D. (2014b), “You Can Say What You Think: Vindicating the Effability of Our Thoughts,” Synthese 191(18): 4431–4450.

Berškytė J. (2021), “Jeremy Is a... Expressive-Relativism and Expressives in Predicative Positions,” Synthese 199, 12517–12539.

Berškytė J. and Stevens G. (2023), “Faultless Disagreement without Contradiction: Expressive-Relativism and Predicates of Personal Taste,” Linguistics and Philosophy 46, 31–64.

DiFranco R. (2017), “Derogation without Words: On the Power of Non-verbal Pejoratives,” Philosophical Psychology 30(6): 784–808.

Drożdżowicz A. (2016), “Descriptive Ineffability Reconsidered,” Lingua 177: 1–16.

Gäb S. (2020), “Ineffability: The Very Concept,” Philosophia 48(5): 1825–1836.

Geurts B. (2007), “Really Fucking Brilliant,” Theoretical Linguistics 33(2): 209–214.

Gutzmann D. (2013), “Expressives and Beyond: An Introduction to Varieties of Use-Conditional Meaning” [in:] Beyond Expressives: Explorations in Use-Conditional Meaning, D. Gutzmann and H.-M. Gärtner (eds.), Leiden: Brill, 1–58.

Gutzmann D. (2015), Use-Conditional Meaning: Studies in Multidimensional Semantics, Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Gutzmann D. (2016), “If Expressivism Is Fun, Go for It” [in:] Subjective Meaning: Alternatives to Relativism, C. Meier and J. van Wijnberger-Huitink (eds.), Berlin: De Gruyter, 21–46.

Hom C. (2008), “The Semantics of Racial Epithets,” The Journal of Philosophy 105(8): 416–440.

Hom C. and May R. (2018), “Pejoratives as Fiction” [in:] Bad Words, D. Sosa (ed.), Oxford: Oxford University Press, 108–131.

Jakobson R. (1960), “Linguistics and Poetics” [in:] Style in Language, T. Sebeok (ed.), Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press, 350–377.

Jay T. and Janschewitz K. (2007), “Filling the Emotion Gap in Linguistic Theory: Commentary on Potts’ Expressive Dimension,” Theoretical Linguistics 33(2): 215– 221.

Jeshion R. (2013), “Expressivism and the Offensiveness of Slurs,” Philosophical Perspectives 27(1): 231–259.

Kaplan D. (1999), The Meaning of Ouch and Oops: Explorations in the Theory of Meaning as Use, Los Angeles: UCLA (manuscript).

Kratzer A. (1999), “Beyond ‘Ouch’ and ‘Oops’: How Descriptive and Expressive Meanings Interact,” paper presented at the Cornell Conference on Theories of ContextDependency, handout available:

Lasersohn P. (2007), “Expressives, Perspective and Presupposition,” Theoretical Linguistics 33(2): 223–230.

Lasersohn P. (2017), Subjectivity and Perspective in Truth-Theoretic Semantics, Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Lindemann B., Ogiwara Y., and Ninomiya Y. (2002), “The Discovery of Umami,” Chemical Senses 27(9): 843–844.

McCready E. (2010), “Varieties of Conventional Implicature,” Semantics and Pragmatics 3(8): 1–57.

Mildenberger C. D. (2017), “Expressives, Majoratives, and Ineffability,” Kriterion – Journal of Philosophy 31(2): 1–16.

Potts C. (2007), “The Expressive Dimension,” Theoretical Linguistics 33(2): 165–198.

Scott M. and Citron G. (2016), “What is Apophaticism? Ways of Talking About an Ineffable God,” European Journal for Philosophy of Religion 8(4): 23–49.

Scott M. and Stevens G. (2019), “An Indexical Theory of Racial Pejoratives,” Analytic Philosophy 60(4): 385–404.

Spackman J. S. (2012), “Expressiveness, Ineffability, and Nonconceptuality,” The Journal of Aesthetics and Art Criticism, 70: 303–314.

Travis C. (1997), “Pragmatics” [in:] A Companion to the Philosophy of Language, B. Hale and C. Wright (eds.), Oxford–Malden, Mass.: Blackwell, 87–107.



Jak cytować

Berškytė, J. (2022). The Ineffable Case of Expressives. Filozofia Nauki, 30(4), 77–99.